How to Listen When You Disagree: Turning Different Perspectives Into Better Ideas

I don’t know about you, but I’m happy the onslaught of political attack ads has ceased. For weeks, every time I turned on the TV or radio I was bombarded with another round of finger-pointing, name calling and vilifying from Republicans and Democrats alike. And social media was even worse (although some of those memes had me LOLing). Very few of those ads let me know where a candidate actually stood on policy.
Somewhere between the third and hundredth attack ad, I started thinking about how often we do a similar version of this in our everyday conversations, and I’m not talking about politics.
A coworker pitches an idea in a meeting and we decide whether we like it before we understand the implications or alternative options.
A colleague from another department pushes back on our plan and we’re already drafting our comeback in our head before hearing them out. We stop listening and start arguing defensively.
Just before the election, I was speaking with a man in our current Leadership Fairfield County cohort. He shared a story that stuck with me because it’s a lesson about perspective and listening that I teach regularly.
His adult son and daughter ended up on opposite sides of the political divide, and one day they were really going at it. Instead of picking a side or telling them to knock it off, he stepped in and set a ground rule. Each of them would take a turn sharing their perspective and beliefs without interruption, and when one finished, the other would get the same chance.
The whole thing took two hours. By the end, they weren’t arguing anymore. They realized they had more in common than they thought, and they walked away with a deeper understanding of and empathy for each other.
What I love about this story is that he never asked them to agree. He changed the rules of the conversation so that listening was the only option.
I’m not suggesting you take this as your sign to start a political debate at the office. What I am saying is that the same skill that helped them find common ground is what helps teams collaborate and solve problems.
When finance, sales and operations look at the same project, each one sees something the others may not because they’re looking at it from a different perspective. What if instead of verbally sparring over whose perspective is right, they took those different perspectives and used them to create a better solution than any of them could on their own?
Here are a few ways to bring that into your next meeting:
Hear them out. I mean actively listen to understand and let them finish. Don’t just wait politely until it’s your turn. If you catch yourself rehearsing your response in your head, that’s your cue to tune back in.
Loop it back. Before you share your view or poke holes in the idea, sum up what you heard and ask, “Did I get that right?” People open up when they feel heard and understood, even if you still disagree.
Ask how, not what. “How did you come to see it that way?” invites a story instead of a debate, and stories are a lot harder to argue with. That’s how you get to the why without putting anyone on the defensive.
Build before you knock it down. Find the part of their idea that works and add to it. Improv calls this “yes, and,” and it’s how a half-formed idea turns into a good one.
Separate the person from the position. You can disagree with someone’s view and still respect the person holding it. That’s what makes it possible to work side by side on Monday morning.
You don’t have to agree with everyone, and you don’t have to shut them down either. Stay curious long enough to hear them out. You never know, you might learn something new or land on a solution nobody would have found alone.
If you want a simple way to put this into practice, try my Communication Compass. It helps you separate the facts from the assumptions, bring in the voices you might be missing and move forward together. Download it FREE and give it a try the next time your team gets stuck.
Speak Success,
Shannon





































Comments